Monday, November 26, 2007

River of Time: A Memoir of Vietnam


#110
Title: River of Time: A Memoir of Vietnam
Author: Jon Swain
Publisher: St. Martin's Press
Year: 1995
Genre: memoir
291 pages

The subtitle appears only on the paperback edition. It's inaccurate since much of this memoir concerns Cambodia.

Swain is one of the reporters who covered the fall of Phnom Penh in the film The Killing Fields. His was the spare passport that the group unsuccessfully tried to counterfiet for Dith Pran. I've read a number of reviews that blast this account of Swain's time in Southeast Asia; most accuse him of admiring the Khmer Rouge (which is not supported by this text), of not writing a complete history (which is not the intention of this book), and/or of being a sybarite whose recollections are primarily of the opium and sex he enjoyed in the region. While it's true that he is nostalgic for his quondam pleasures, I saw very clearly that he contrasts his younger and more mature perspectives, that he counters the hedonism and cynicism of the pre-war period with the wars' horrific effects, and that what he longs for (as in so many narratives of transition) is an imagined gentleness and naivite. I'm certainly a feminist and have my own concerns about the genre of the war narrative as told by men, in which women are only gruff authorities, prostitutes, or protective mothers. However, Swain's narrative is much more complex than that, and often succeeds in showing the transformation of peoples and countries as well as of Swain himself.

No comments:

Post a Comment