Sunday, July 11, 2010

Specials


#478
Title: Specials
Author: Scott Westerfeld
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Year: 2007
372 pages

Sadly, the weakest of the trilogy. Again, Tally's brain is screwed with; again, her loyalties are divided; again, self-mutilation leads to enlightenment. I understand the physiology of this, but feel that Westerfeld lets it stand without adequate critique. Similarly, Tally's "special" body is grotesque but still described as if it's "cruel pretty." The ending has its entertaining moments but seems too easy, and I'm not convinced. I'm similarly not convinced that the Rusties would rather die than get out of their cars, which appears to be the explanation for why an oil-eating bug wrecked civilization. My recommendation, barring a fantastic 4th book, is to read the first and stop there.

No comments:

Post a Comment